Back to Blog
    SEO

    Google on Not Publishing Commodity Content

    Google's clearest signal yet: write what only you could write.

    Vijayata Vasnani April 28, 2026 9 min read
    Search results page on a laptop, representing Google's evolving stance on commodity content

    Quick Summary

    At Google Search Central Live in Toronto (April 21, 2026), Danny Sullivan laid out the difference between commodity and non-commodity content. The framework rests on three pillars — unique, specific, authentic — and the data already shows pages with proprietary insight gaining visibility while templated and AI-farmed content collapses. This is what Sullivan said, why it matters now, who is winning under the new bar, and a practical playbook for adapting your content strategy.

    A significant shift unfolded at the Google Search Central Live event in Toronto on April 21, 2026, the first of its kind ever hosted in Canada. While much of the SEO world was parsing snippets and debating AI Mode, Google's own Search Liaison Danny Sullivan stepped up and delivered a message that cuts to the heart of what content actually needs to be in 2026: not just useful, or optimised, but something original that carries a perspective no one else can replicate.

    There was no algorithm update attached to this message. No rollout, no penalties, no immediate disruption. Instead, Sullivan outlined a broader philosophy, the one that has already been influencing how Google evaluates and ranks content over the past several months.

    Toronto skyline, the host city for Google Search Central Live 2026
    Photo by Conor Samuel on Unsplash

    What Exactly Did Danny Sullivan Say?

    According to Search Engine Roundtable, Sullivan spoke at length about the importance of producing "unique, authentic, and non-commodity content," laying out a concrete framework for what separates the two. His framework rested on three pillars:

    PillarWhat it meansThe opposite (commodity)
    UniqueShares original insight or data others don't have (e.g., a company reveals results from its own experiment).Repackages what's already ranking into another 'ultimate guide'.
    SpecificFocuses on a defined scenario with clear context (budget, audience, location, constraints).Broad advice meant to apply to everyone, everywhere.
    AuthenticBuilt on first-hand experience, with real examples, outcomes, or lessons.Compiled from secondary sources with no lived experience behind it.

    Sullivan illustrated this with industry-specific examples that are almost relatable for anyone who has managed a content calendar in the past three years. As summarised by Digital Phablet, for a running store, commodity content looks like "Top 10 Tips When Buying Running Shoes," covering sizing, arch support, and cushioning. Non-commodity content, on the other hand, is a detailed breakdown of why a specific customer's shoes deteriorated after 400 miles, explaining exactly how their gait pattern caused the foam to collapse laterally.

    This distinction between broadly useful and genuinely insightful content is central to how Google evaluates content. As John Mueller put it, "Focus on making unique, non-commodity content that visitors from Search and your own readers will find helpful and satisfying." (May 21, 2025)

    In short, if anyone could write it, it's a commodity. If only you could write it, that's what Google is rewarding.

    Why Now? The AI Context You Can't Ignore

    Person working with AI tools on a laptop, illustrating the rise of AI-generated content
    Photo by Matheus Bertelli on Pexels

    The timing isn't random. As JC Chouinard, Senior SEO Strategist at Tripadvisor, pointed out after attending the event, AI has made it incredibly easy to create content. So in response, Google is becoming more selective about what it actually includes in search results.

    That's why the status "Crawled – Currently not indexed" is showing up more often. It doesn't always mean something is broken. In many cases, it simply means Google has seen the page but doesn't think it's valuable or unique enough to show in search.

    The numbers are already reflecting this shift. An analysis by NEURONwriter found:

    Pages with proprietary data / first-hand case studies
    +15 to +25%
    Templated or rewritten content
    −30 to −50%
    Large-scale AI content farms
    Up to −80%

    Source: NEURONwriter analysis after the March 2026 core update.

    "Reading between the lines, if your users can be satisfied with an AI Overview, you are NGMI."

    A Real-World Example: The Three Industries Sullivan Used

    Sullivan didn't stay abstract. He walked through three industries side by side, and the contrast is instructive:

    IndustryCommodity versionNon-commodity version
    Running StoreTop 10 Things to Consider When Buying Running Shoes (sizing, arch support, cushioning).Why This Customer's Shoes Collapsed After 400 Miles, with a gait analysis video explaining wear pattern breakdown.
    Real Estate7 Tips for First-Time Homebuyers (pre-approval, location, budgeting).Why We Waived the Inspection and Saved $15k, a specific bidding war case study with a PVC sewer line finding.
    Interior Design2024 Kitchen Trends You Need to See (green cabinets, brass hardware from Pinterest).Why I Refused to Install Marble for a Family of Five, with grape juice and turmeric stain tests to prove the point.

    Notice the pattern: every non-commodity example involves a real situation, a specific person, a documented outcome, and knowledge that had to be earned. You cannot produce these with a prompt and a keyword list.

    Brands Already Doing This and Winning

    Marketing team reviewing analytics charts on a screen, representing brands winning with original content
    Photo by fauxels on Pexels

    Several brands have been building non-commodity content moats for years and their organic performance reflects it.

    What the SEO Community Is Saying

    Group of marketers in conversation, representing community reactions to the Google update
    Photo by fauxels on Pexels

    The industry response has been immediate. As Chris Long noted, Google is now explicitly pushing for "non-commodity content" built on real-world experience and data.

    Meanwhile, Leighanne Makrygian, the Founder at LA Search, emphasises that the "Commodity vs. Non-Commodity" debate is all about balancing the scale, and not completely eliminating one for the other.

    Another key takeaway came from Anne Bui, who attended the Google Search Central Live event. She explains the essence of this update in a simple way: don't overcomplicate things, and just create what's genuinely useful for the user.

    The Nuance Sullivan Didn't Skip

    To Sullivan's credit, the message wasn't "commodity content is dead, panic." As Hobo Web notes, commodity content isn't spam; Google still surfaces it for quick factual queries or when that format genuinely serves user intent. Glossaries, definitions, and reference pages can still have a place, particularly for feeding AI knowledge bases and earning citations in AI Overviews and chatbots.

    The real risk, Sullivan implied, is over-reliance on commodity content as a strategy. If your entire editorial calendar is built on keyword-matched articles that synthesise what's already online, you're in a precarious position. But if commodity content sits alongside a core of genuinely unique, experience-driven work, you're likely fine.

    Sullivan also addressed AI content directly: AI tools are fine for research and structure. What's not fine is using them to mass-produce pages that add no new value. That's what triggers Google's Scaled Content Abuse algorithm. It's not the presence of AI writing, but the absence of genuine contribution.

    "Good SEO is good GEO. At its heart, it's still about creating great content for people. The sites that will thrive in AI search are those that have always been doing SEO right: publishing genuine expertise, maintaining strong technical foundations, and thinking first about the human reader."

    — Danny Sullivan, Director of Google Search, at Google Search Central Live Toronto

    The Practical Takeaway: What Should You Do?

    Content strategist working through a content audit at a desk, representing the practical playbook
    Photo by Anna Shvets on Pexels

    If you're a content lead, brand strategist, or SEO manager reading this, the question isn't "what does this mean for my rankings?" It's "what do I know that no one else does?" Here's a framework for auditing your content against Sullivan's standard:

    Run the replication test

    For each piece of content, ask: could a well-trained AI, with access to your top 10 competitors, produce this in 20 minutes? If yes, it's a commodity. If it draws on your proprietary data, real client outcomes, documented experiments, or lived expertise, it's non-commodity.

    Interview your own people

    The most consistent source of non-commodity content isn't an agency. It's your sales team, field engineers, and customer success managers. They've seen the actual situations your customers face — turn that experience into content.

    Stop writing 'ultimate guides'. Start writing case files.

    A case study about one customer's specific problem, documented with real numbers and real decisions, is more valuable than a 5,000-word complete guide that covers everything shallowly.

    Show your work

    Add author bios, credentials, and first-hand case studies. If you tested something, show the test. If a customer shared data with you, publish it (with permission). The evidence of lived experience is what Google and readers can't get anywhere else.

    The Bigger Picture

    Shaun Anderson at Hobo Web frames this best: what Google announced in Toronto is essentially "Helpful Content 2.0." The Helpful Content update of 2022–23 told us to write for people. The commodity/non-commodity framework tells us that writing for people isn't enough anymore. We have to write things that only people with our specific experience could write.

    It's a higher bar but a far more honest one. The brands that will thrive here aren't just scaling content; they're deepening it. They bring perspective, proof, and lived experience to the table because that's what makes their content impossible to replace.

    What Danny Sullivan articulated in Toronto wasn't a warning but a clarification. Google isn't changing what good content is; it's getting better at recognising it. The advantage now doesn't go to those who publish the most. It goes to those who have something worth saying and the courage to say it differently.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Want to work with us?

    Book a free 30-minute discovery call with our team.

    Let's Talk